Skip to Content

Orange Creamsicle Popsicles (dairy free, Paleo & GAPS friendly)

When I was little, I remember my mom making popsicles very similiar to these, but she used orange juice concentrate and cane sugar instead of pure unsweetened orange juice and honey/stevia. In any case, I loved the popsicles she made for my brother and I, and wanted to recreate them for my girls, just with healthier ingredients.


Orange Creamsicle Popsicles Recipe
Yields 8 – 10 popsicles

2 cup unsweetened orange juice (I use the Naked brand of orange juice, it has no added sugar, no preservatives, non-GMO, and it’s vegan)
3/4 cup plain yogurt (you can use dairy yogurt, or coconut milk yogurt for dairy free/vegan)
2 – 3 tablespoons raw runny honey, or organic agave nectar, or coconut nectar, etc.
1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract
10 drops liquid vanilla stevia (I use the NuNatural’s stevia brand. If you don’t like to use stevia, simply increase the amount of honey/liquid sweetener used)

  1. Combine all ingredients in a blender and blend until smooth.
  2. Taste mixture and add more sweetener if desired.
  3. Pour into popsicle molds and freeze overnight.

This recipe is linked to Allergy Free Wednesdays, Fat Tuesday, Slightly Indulgent Tuesday, Gluten Free Wednesdays, Simply Lives Thursday, Frugal Days Sustainable Ways, Wellness Weekend, and the Gluten Free Homemaker.


Grain Free Fried Alaskan Rex Sole
← Previous
Homemade Kimchi
Next →


Thursday 25th of June 2015

I love the idea of theses, and love the molds. Where could I find these molds, please.



Monday 6th of July 2015

On, Sue! :)

Paleo Diet for Kids – Transition to Kid Friendly Paleo Food

Monday 6th of October 2014

[…] Orange Creamsicle Popsicles (dairy free, Paleo): These are a great summertime treat, and taste just like the real thing! […]


Wednesday 30th of April 2014

do you think kefir would work for these?? i don't make yogurt too often anymore but always have tons of kefir


Wednesday 30th of April 2014

Hi Joanna, I haven't tried using kefir in this recipe, but I would imagine it would work just fine! ;) Megan

Cherry Vanilla Italian Soda (No sugar added)Allergy Free Alaska

Friday 2nd of August 2013

[…] ice cream maker is broken (I just ordered a replacement piece), so we’ve been enjoying popsicles, sugar free lemonade, and Cherry Vanilla Italian Sodas to beat the heat. As a rule, we don’t […]

Cassidy @ Cassidy's Craveable Creations

Saturday 15th of June 2013

I made these today and they were DELISH - perfect creamsicle flavor!!!! Thanks!



Sunday 16th of June 2013

So glad you enjoyed them, Cassidy! :) Hugs, Megan